2023-2024 Champions – Avalanche; Mark Cornyn, Wayne Wehrle, Mark Elias, Korie Bruce, Carlo Kazmierczyk
2022-2023 Champions – Rangers; DJ Gallucci, Marc Stock, Harry Stock, Dave DePaul, Chuck Stock
2021-2022 Champions – Sabres; CJ Caligiuri, Dan Gage, Josh Thompson, Richard Kimak, John Pulkownik, Brian Lengyel, Dale Humphries
2020-2021 Champions – Devils; Jim McCann, Chris Hoblak, Carlo Kazmierczyk, Jacob Bostedo, Nathan Bostedo
2019 – 2020 Champions; Season Cancelled Early Due to Covid-19 Pandemic
2018-2019 Champions – Kings; Andy Vandemark, Steve Bobick, Chet Grassi, Mark Cornyn, Ed Decker
2017-2018 Champions – Oilers; Jamison Judge, Tom Cunningham, Roy McDonald, Grant Wolf
2016-2017 Champions – Stars; Ethan Weiss, John Corbett, Tim Corbett, Shawn Hoffman, Justin Hoffman
2015-2016 Champions – Penguins; Ken Newman, Jim Wargo, Jeff Fischer, Carl Anderson Sr., Carl Anderson Jr., and Ronnie
2014-2015 Champions – Kings; John Corbett, Mike Soltis, Ed Gray, Frank Yurkovich, Larry Yanyo
2013-2014 Champions – Predators; Gerald Staab, Rob Wojtaszek, Alan Staab, Tom Brophy, Brian Staab
2012-2013 Champions – Panthers; BJ Pugh, Ed Nassan, Robbie Yeschenko, Brandon Snyder, Joe Bytzura
2011-2012 Champions; Chris Dee, Brian Lengyel, Derek Bost, Ray Kopchak, Larry Stearns
2010-2011 Champions; Jake Bradich, Chuck Race, Dan Moore, Skip Race, Gary Martin
2009-2010 Champions; Joe Bytzura, Al Yeschenko, Rob Yeschenko, Steve Bundy, Brad Yeschenko
2008-2009 Champions; Larry Hoffman, Joe Esper Sr., Rock Eckley, Jerry Bajus, Fr. Eugene
2007-2008 Champions; Gerald Staab, Brian Staab, Rich Kohl, Ray Staab, Alan Staab
2006-2007 Champions; Brian Yeschenko, Rob Yeschenko, Brad Yeschenko, Steve Bundy, Al Yeschenko
2005-2006 Champions; Matt Schanck, Ray Staab, Alan Staab, Rich Kohl, Brian Staab
2004-2005 Champions; John Jasek, Dave Ackerman, Ed Skweres, Bill Harvey Sr., Bill Harvey Jr.
2003-2004 Champions; Jeff Esper, Joe Esper Sr., Joe Esper Jr., Larry Amanti, Geno Pisciottano
2002-2003 Champions; Chris Dunkerley, Mike Hepner, Mark Hepner, Scott Harvey, Jim Hepner
2001-2002 Champions; Bill Bost, Tim Dee, Chris Dee, Mark Schaefer, Derek Bost
2000 – 2001 Champions; Mark Longo, Jerry Snyder, Jeff Martin, Bobby Etzel, Bill Crevar
1999 – 2000 Champions; Jim Hepner, Scott Harvey, Mike Herbinko, Mark Hepner, Mike Hepner
1998 – 1999 Champions; Milo Samudosky, Frank Tovlin, Nick Uhren, Lee Mowry, Phil Janocko
1997 – 1998 Champions; Sonny Lutz, Jeff Wardle, Jim Hast, Gene Conrad, Dan McLaughlin
1996-1997 Champions; Chris Hoblak, Chris Hrizo, Brian Lengyel, Joe Pulkownik, John Pulkownik
1995-1996 Champions; Gene Conrad, Ray Cush, Vince Delandro, Jim Hast, Sonny Lutz
1994-1995 Champions; Butch Strang, Ed Skweres, Conrad Bollins, Bill Broadright, Rob Solack
1993-1994 Champions; Jerry Snyder, Rip Collins, Vince Delandro, Jay Saunders, Joe Kesich
1992 – 1993 Champions; Cliff Crevar, Frank Javorsky, Ed Givens, Harold Andres, George Moser